Synopsis:
Recipients of wishes meet their fates based on the choices they have made. Amanda Collins tells the story of how she recovered her memories of her past life.
Loeb & Bachalo credited as "storytellers," but interview in Vertigo: Winter's Edge (DC, 1998 series) #3 (January 2000) suggests Bachalo mostly did art. Story has a mix of black and white and color art.
Notes:
Back cover illustrated with black and white art from The Witching Hour (DC, 1999 series) #2, page 1 and from #3, pages 1 & 48; background art is grey-on-black version of artwork from #1, page 6.